An Apples-to-Electrons Comparison of Low-Carbon Transportation Options
An Apples-to-Electrons Comparison of Low-Carbon Transportation Options
An Apples-to-Electrons Comparison of Low-Carbon Transportation Options
Program: Catalyst Grants
Program details » | All Catalyst Grants projects »

Photo credit: A Healthier Michigan
“This project aligns with U-M's strategic interests to support a transition to low-carbon intensity transportation and will allow U-M to expand its understanding of the impacts of renewable fuels on our operations.”
Project Summary
Renewable fuels have the potential to significantly reduce carbon emissions compared to fossil fuels without requiring new infrastructure, mineral resource extraction, or carbon-intensive manufacturing. However, a key barrier to widespread adoption is a lack of end-user confidence, particularly concerning operational performance and fuel economy.
This project used the U-M campus as its laboratory, demonstrating that renewable fuels pose no operational issues and, in this test case, delivered nearly a 75% reduction in CO₂ emissions compared to fossil fuels.
The research team conducted side-by-side comparisons of a refuse truck and a campus bus, each operated on diesel and, separately, on 100% renewable fuel. They evaluated fuel economy, vehicle performance, life-cycle impacts, and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.
Conducted in partnership with U-M Transportation and Waste Services and in consultation with Chevron Renewable Energy Group (CREG), this project contributes to a growing body of research focused on bus electrification and alternative renewable fuels. The project also supported the development of low-carbon options for heavy-duty vehicles that can not be easily electrified.
Moreover, U-M, CREG, and other fleet operators now have a real-world comparison of ownership costs and GHG emissions reductions associated with renewable fuels. U-M Transportation and Waste Services has used the findings to inform its investments in the transportation system, weighing whether to pursue decarbonization through a transition to 100% renewable fuels, 100% vehicle electrification, or a blended approach.
The project fostered a collaborative relationship between the Auto Lab and stakeholders at U-M Transportation Services and CREG. In particular, the grant collaboration paved the way for CREG to launch a major renewable fuels research project at the Auto Lab to compare additional renewable fuel blends and assess their performance relative to fossil fuels and electricity. Project findings were presented to a range of stakeholders at conferences and workshops and also served as the foundation for a Master's student’s thesis.
This project received a $10,000 Catalyst Grant in 2022.
Project team: André L. Boehman, PI (Engineering | U-M Ann Arbor); Shelie Miller, Co-I (SEAS | U-M Ann Arbor); William McAllister (U-M Transportation and Waste Services); Scott Guenther (U-M Transportation and Waste Services); Samuel Moran (U-M Transportation and Waste Services); David Slade (Renewable Energy Group, Inc.).