The promise and risks of framing climate change as a migration issue

The promise and risks of framing climate change as a migration issue

Program: Carbon Neutrality Acceleration Program
Program details » | All Carbon Neutrality Acceleration Program projects »

Stack of newspapers

Photo by congerdesign/Pixabay

Project Summary

As climate change intensifies, more people are being displaced, both across borders and within their own countries. Media and policymakers are increasingly framing climate change as a migration issue, but how does this narrative shape public opinion? This CNAP-funded research project tested how different ways of framing climate migration influence public beliefs about climate change, attitudes toward migrants, and support for related policies. Using a mix of experimental and qualitative studies with national and Midwestern representative and regionally targeted samples, the team examined different ways of framing climate migration and how they influence public support for related climate policies. These frames included whether climate migration was presented as domestic or international, framed as a threat or opportunity, or grounded in personal stories versus statistics. Their findings revealed a complex picture.

Key Findings

  • People who are more aware of climate migration tend to also be more concerned about climate change and support climate policies (Gillis et al., 2023)
  • Linking climate change to international migration often increased anxiety and anti-migrant sentiment, particularly among certain political groups, and did not boost support for climate policy (Gillis et al., 2023; Raimi et al., 2024). In contrast, reactions to domestic climate migration, such as Americans displaced by floods or other climate-related events, were sometimes more constructive in increasing support for mitigation, though only if the messaging was presented as a personal story about one exemplar climate migrant (Raimi et al., 2024).
  • Emphasizing the potential benefits of receiving climate migrants in regions like the Great Lakes, such as economic or population growth, reduced fear, and, in some cases, created excitement. These responses contrasted with messages that framed migration as a threat, whether through realistic concerns like housing demand or symbolic concerns like cultural change.
  • Information about climate migration increases perceived risks of both domestic and international climate migration, especially when talking about international migration (Gillis et al., 2023; Raimi et al., 2024).
  • Messages that framed domestic migration in terms of symbolic threats (like cultural change) tended to provoke more fear and negative attitudes, while messages emphasizing material benefits (like economic gains) led to greater positivity even two weeks after exposure.

Ultimately, the team concludes that while climate migration is an unavoidable topic, it must be communicated with care. Some narratives may backfire, but tailored, evidence-based messaging may help inform public understanding and guide effective climate adaptation strategies. The insights from these projects were shared through academic publications, presentations at conferences, workshops, and invited speaker sessions, helping shape broader conversations about climate migration. 

This team received a $137,000 CNAP faculty research grant.

Project Team

Kaitlin Raimi, PI (Ford | U-M Ann Arbor); Julia Lee Cunningham, Co-I (Ross School of Business | U-M Ann Arbor); Nathaniel Geiger (SEAS | U-M Ann Arbor); Ash Gillis (Pennsylvania State University); Melanie Sarge (Indiana University)
 

Journal Articles

Resources